We get a lot of great questions about the difference between our two remineralizing formulas, Original Puddy and Primal Puddy,so we wanted to break it down for you in a super simple way.
The good news? You really can't go wrong.
Both are 100% natural, deeply nourishing, and made to support your body's ability to rebuild enamel, soothe sensitivity, and remineralize early decay.
They have different personalities, but both with the same ultimate intention. Many people ask which one is more effective, but I feel like that is something only time will tell. The OG Puddy has a history of use that stands behind its efficacy, but we are having *amazing* results with the Primal Puddy too! Ultimately, I think whichever one you are called to and believe in the most will be the best for you!
Both Primal Puddy and Original Puddy are designed to support healthy teeth and gums through remineralization. They deliver the same intended outcome—the difference is simply how they get there.
Choose the formula that best aligns with your preferences, sensitivities, and ingredient philosophy.
PRIMAL PUDDY
ORIGINAL PUDDY
Animal-based, herb-free formula
Vegetarian, herb-forward formula
Grass-fed bovine micro-hydroxyapatite
Coral-derived micro-hydroxyapatite
Grass-fed tallow base
Organic sesame oil base
Colostrum and nutrient-dense animal ingredients
Ayurvedic and Traditional Chinese herbal ingredients
Rich, creamy texture
Smooth, lighter texture
Mild earthy scent
Mild herbal scent
Same Goal. Different Approach.
Primal Puddy is ideal for those who prefer nutrient-dense animal-based ingredients and an herb-free formula.
Original Puddy is ideal for those who prefer a plant-based approach featuring time-honored herbal traditions.
Neither is stronger, better, or more effective than the other—they simply take different paths to support the same outcome. Choose the one whose ingredients resonate most with you, or alternate between both depending on your preferences.
Still unsure? Start with whichever formula appeals to you most. Many customers love both.
